Full Proceedings of Reference Case Agaist J. Qazi Faiz



Reference case against Justice Qazi Faiz Issa in Supreme Court

 

 A ten-member full court headed by Justice Umar Ata Bandial is hearing the case. Justice Umar Ata Bandial directed to keep social distance at the beginning of the hearing

 People are sitting close to each other in the court, Justice Omar Ata Bandial

 Sit at a distance from each other, Justice Omar Ata Bandial

 Former Law Minister Forough Naseem appears in court

 I am representing the federation and Shahzad Akbar, Forough Naseem

 I am also a party in the case. Irfan Qadir will appear on my behalf, Forough Naseem


 Barrister Forough Naseem represented the federal government

 Justice Faiz Issa objected to Forough Naseem's advocacy

 Forough Naseem has great respect but he objects to the representation of the federation, said lawyer Munir A. Malik

 Forough Naseem will have to produce a certificate from the Attorney General to appear, Munir A. Malik

 Rules do not allow the federal government to hire a private lawyer, lawyer Munir A. Malik said

 If any public prosecutor from the Attorney General's Office is not qualified to appear, then the Attorney General has to give a certificate, lawyer Munir A. Malik said.
 
 I will tell you not to raise objections and let the case go ahead, Justice Omar Ata Bandial

 Summer vacations are also about to begin, Justice Omar Ata Bandial said

 We want to take the case further, Justice Omar Ata Bandial
 I have informed the court in writing of the objections, Munir O Malik

 All objections are in accordance with the Constitution and the law and the rules of the Supreme Court, Munir A. Malik

 I do not want to waste time. Let the court see the objections itself, Munir O Malik

The objections raised against me are of no particular importance, Forough Naseem

 In the case of Rasheed Ahmed, it has been clarified, Forough Naseem

 A written request has also been filed on the appearance of Forough Naseem, Munir A. Malik

 The federal government has the right to represent and defend itself, Munir A. Malik

 The former attorney general was representing the federal government, Justice Omar Ata Bandial said

Munir A  Malik, don't fall into small things, Justice Umar Ata Bandial

 We need help to reach a proper decision, Justice Omar Ata Bandial

We want to complete this trial before the summer holidays.  Justice Omar Ata Bandial

 It would be appropriate for you to withdraw your objections, otherwise we will decide, Justice Omar Ata Bandial

The law should be enforced in the country, Munir A. Malik

This is a case of justice and transparency, Munir O Malik

Attorney General has issued the required certificate, Forough Naseem

 Bring Attorney General's certificate on record, Justice Umar Ata Bandial

There is an objection to the language of the written petition of Justice Qazi Faiz Issa, Forough Naseem

Forough Naseem, you talk about the merits of the case, leave out what is said in the petition, Justice Umar Ata Bandial

Three London properties are in the name of the children and wife of the esteemed judge, Forough Naseem

This fact has been acknowledged by the petitioners, Forough Naseem

The case before the court is a case of misconduct of a judge under Article 209, Forough Naseem

The real question is from what sources the properties were purchased, the money trail, Forough Naseem

How money went out to buy properties from Pakistan, Forough Naseem

 If Justice Qazi Faiz Issa does not give money trail, then it is misconduct, Forough Naseem

Honorable Judge is highly respected in the society, Forough Naseem

 The properties are in the names of the wife and children, Justice Mansoor Ali Shah

 First state that the properties belong to Justice Qazi Faiz Issa, Justice Mansoor Ali Shah

 It is the petitioner's job to prove that the properties do not belong to him, Forough Naseem

If my son buys a property, will I be responsible for it, Justice Mansoor Ali Shah

Prove if Justice Faiz Issa's children and wife are under his care, Justice Yahya Afridi

 If the child and wife are not under sponsorship, then it is the responsibility of the petitioner to state the source from which the property was purchased, Forough Naseem
 
 Instead of responding to the show cause, he filed a petition, Forough Naseem said

 Honorable judge says children and wife should be asked about money trail and resources: Justice Umar Ata Bandial

 How can one ask a question by ignoring the names of those who have properties, Justice Mansoor Ali Shah

 What is the problem with the properties of judges in the federation, Justice Qazi Amen

Can judges be questioned without evidence and complaints?  Justice Qazi Amen

If there is no concrete evidence then why the credibility of judges is questioned, Justice Qazi Amen

 Isn't the government's move against the independence of judges and judiciary?  Justice Qazi Amen

 The case you are presenting with arguments is different from the reference, Justice Muneeb Akhtar

Today you are filing a case on the basis of Income Tax Act, Justice Muneeb Akhtar

The reference did not base the income tax law, Justice Muneeb Akhtar said

 It is the job of the Judicial Council to remove or approve the reference, Forough Naseem

Give arguments on the point that the first reference is malicious, Justice Sajjad Ali Shah

The discussion on the reference in the constitutional petition will be of scholarly status, Forough Naseem

Judicial Council may review and reject reference: Forough Naseem

 Judicial Council issues show cause notice after hearing Attorney General and Honorable Judge: Forough Naseem

 The show cause notice has its own significance, Justice Omar Ata Bandial said

 The petition also alleges malice, Justice Omar Ata Bandial said

 Honorable judge's lawyer reluctant to give arguments on show cause notice: Justice Umar Ata Bandial

 Munir A Malik gave arguments on the admissibility of the petition, Justice Omar Ata Bandial said

 Show cause notice issued in the case of Justice Qazi Faiz Issa, Forough Naseem

 Reference matures after show cause notice issued, Forough Naseem

 How the reference was prepared, how the content of the reference was compiled, Justice Maqbool Baqir

 First of all, give arguments on the preparation of reference, Justice Maqbool Baqir

 How the Judicial Council summoned the former Chief Justice without show cause notice, Justice Faisal Arab

 No show cause notice was issued to former Chief Justice, Forough Naseem

 Article 209 was not followed in the reference of the former Chief Justice, Forough Naseem

 In the current presidential reference, Article 209 has been fully implemented, Forough Naseem

 Forough Naseem: I do not agree with your argument, Justice Muneeb Akhtar

 It seems that you want to file a case on show cause notice, Justice Muneeb Akhtar

 This means that the reference before the show cause notice was not just a piece of paper, Justice Muneeb Akhtar

 Preparation of reference before show cause notice may be judicial review, Forough Naseem

 The petitioner alleges that the entire reference process is illegal and malicious, Justice Maqbool Baqir said

 At the first stage, it would be appropriate to give every argument on this issue, Justice Maqbool Baqir

 Every action or order must be in accordance with the law, Justice Maqbool Baqir

 Article 211 applies after show cause notice is issued, Forough Naseem

 Proceedings of the Judicial Council cannot be challenged after the application of Article 211, Forough Naseem said

 If we do not accept your argument, then will you not give arguments at the stage of preparation of reference, Justice Sajjad Ali Shah

 I will give arguments on the preparation of reference, Forough Naseem

 Then first of all give arguments on the preparation of reference, Justice Sajjad Ali Shah

 It has taken half an hour to reach the real point, Justice Mansoor Ali Shah
 

 
 By mistake, these documents could not be submitted to the court, Forough Naseem

 Munir A. Malik gave arguments on the same point for two days, Justice Sajjad Ali Shah.

 The government team was present during the arguments but did not file a complaint, Justice Sajjad Ali Shah said

 London registry papers are not fake, Forough Naseem

 The petitioner did not get a chance to argue on this complaint, Justice Sajjad Ali Shah

 How to review a complaint without finding it on record.  Justice Sajjad Ali Shah

 The federal government is wrong on this issue, Justice Sajjad Ali Shah
 
Justice Qazi Faiz Issa case hearing adjourned till 11:30 am tomorrow

 The Supreme Court sought answers / arguments from Forough Naseem on four questions

 It is alleged that the material was collected illegally, the court said

 You have to give evidence on illegal collection of material, court

 Why the complaint was sent to the Assets Recovery Unit, the court said

 Why the complaint was not sent to the President or the Judicial Council, the court said

 These questions have to be answered by the court

 At the end of the day, I was asked to represent the federation, Forough Naseem

 Giving you another 12 hours to prepare, court

 In what capacity did the Assets Recovery Unit gather information, Justice Maqbool Baqir said
 

Justice Qazi Faiz Issa case hearing adjourned till 11:30 am tomorrow
  

Post a Comment

0 Comments